This
review assumes that players are right-handed - left handed players should
reverse any references.
The Package
A 32 page Black and white booklet-based tutorial containing an audio
CD. The CD has Steáfán reading the book pretty much verbatim and illustrating
the discussed pattern by playing either solo or in mini performance.
The product is aimed directly at beginning bodhranii, those who need
to get the fundamentals upon which they can build their skills.
Lesson Delivery Method
The tutorial can be used either by being read, listened to, or most
likely a combination of both.
The CD versions of the book chapters are delivered in audio 'chunks'
representing the duration and content of the written chapters. Rhythmic patterns
are not available as separate CD tracks and it is unfortunately difficult for a
beginner to repeat specific passages for practise because of this.
Rhythms are notated in Steáfán's own manner using a series of up and
down arrows of varying scale to indicate stroke direction / accent. Left hand
actions are illustrated using a circle showing where to strike and where &
how to place move and press with the hand. Hand-drawn illustrations are used
where appropriate.
Using the tutorial.
The chapter headings vary in length as can be seen from the chapter
and CD track list below
-
About Bodhrans (CD track 3 -
3:27)
-
The Cipin or Tipper (CD track 4 -
2:06)
-
Getting Started (CD track 5 -
3:39)
-
Dynamic Playing (CD track 6 -
1:17)
-
Skin Sounds (CD track 7 -
5:37)
-
Reels 1 (CD track 8 -
4:14)
-
Jigs 1 (CD track 9 -
4:35)
-
Reels 2 (CD track 10 -
5:17)
-
Jigs2 (CD track 11 -
5:53)
-
Triplets (CD track 12 -
2:51)
-
Basics to remember
-
Care & maintenance
- Extra
tunes to Play along with (CD track 13 - 2:35)
The
tutorial structure follows the standard path of introduction to the drum and the
Kerry Style of playing viz; the technique; Right hand / left hand duties; reels;
jigs & triplets. As this is a beginner text it stops at triplets. In the original text it goes
on to Rim Playing, complex reels & jigs, other forms and 15 pages of tunes
[?].
The written passages are brief and illustrated throughout
using steafan's notation, Reels are covered in about 700 words in two sections
using the wa-ter-me-lon method and supported by about 20 images and 8 stroke
indicators. Jigs are covered as Pine-ap-ple_Ap-ri-cot, about 3-400 words and a
dozen or so visual panels.
User
Friendliness
This is a beginners text, it has been written
as such and does exactly what it claims to do; it rightly assumes no prior
knowledge of the drum
or its playing techniques. The introduction and main body to the reels section
is extremely basic and functional but leaves you in no doubt as to the key
elements of which you need to be aware. Advocating playing into the drum (i.e.
hitting an imaginary spot just below the surface) is excellent advice that I
have not seen often repeated in the other tutorials.
The accompanying CD although essentially being
a re-reading of the chapters, serves its purpose well and correlates well to the
illustrations. The addition of tunes to play along with is also a useful
inclusion as beginning players may not have examples of music
featuring the bodhran, obviously the main benefit is in giving them material
with which to practise the techniques in the book as well as experimenting
further.
I find Steafan's personal style of delivery
and choice of terminology to be wholly appropriate to the beginner bodhran
player. I do have to say that whilst the author's own notation system is
functional, I find can see it as being potentially restrictive in that it only
prepares a bodhrani for use of that particular system, it seems an unnecessary
re-invention when compared to adaptations of the more universal western notation
system. WIth that said it should not stop you from seriously considering this as
an introduction to playing the bodhran, the end justifies the means.
What do I think?
Provided that you are only after basic
introductory information I think this is an excellent wee book that should
provide the introduction to the bodhran that an absolute beginner would require,
the addition of the CD makes this an extremely useful resource. If you already
have the basic skills then you will find this perhaps a little limited for you
although there is always useful information to be gained from looking at others'
approaches.
Given that the package reviewed includes a 45
minute CD version of the book, it only serves to widen my smile and to improve
its value rating. In my opinion at this price this represents excellent value
for money at the cost of about 10 minutes of tuition.
Am I Glad I bought it?
Yes absolutely
Would I recommend it?
For an absolute beginner looking for a
tutorial to accompany the purchase of their first drum I recommend it without
hesitation.
Paul
Marshall - January 2004
Trackback(0)
 |